6 Tips for Writing Personalized Physical Education Report Card Comments

One of my least favorite parts about being a PE teacher is writing report card comments.

My district has a very strict policy about individualizing physical education report card comments, and report card comments in general.

This makes report card comments a very busy time with having to write a minimum of 180 individualized PE report card comments.

The good thing about me having to write all these comments is that I can share my process. Here are 6 tips for making writing personalized Phys Ed report card comments quick and easy!

Are you looking for a free student report card comment handout? Click here to join the resource library.

Be Proactive Before Writing PE Report Card Comments

I’ve found that the best way to make writing Phys Ed report card comments easy is to be proactive with my assessment before I even think about writing my comments. 

Grade With Each Standard

A lot of my assessment comes from observation of my students. In a two-week unit, I typically do about 4 days of assessment. 

For each of the days, I choose a couple of general standards to focus on and let the students know ahead of time. I walk around and watch my students throughout the lesson and give them a mark. I continue to update the assessment throughout the class. 

This makes it easier for me to give students an accurate overall mark when it comes to my report cards. 

I use the marks I assign students to help when writing my comments, which I’ll talk about a bit later on in the post.

Take Cruising Notes

While I’m walking around doing my assessments I always write down some notes as well. I create my class list so that I have longer sections that I can write in.

I take notes on how my students are successful and the areas they are working on. These typically include skills, teamwork/cooperation, and participation/effort because these are the main focuses of my curriculum.

I always keep these notes handy so that if I’m not doing assessment on a particular day, I can add notes if I notice my students doing particularly well or poorly in a specific area.

Make Writing Personalized PE Report Card Comments Easy

Have Your Students Help Write Personalized Physical Education Report Card Comments

Okay, hear me out. I don’t mean have your students actually write their comments for you, but I find it really helpful to get their feedback about their experience in physical education.

Student Check-in

A couple of weeks before my PE report card comments are due, I give my students a check-in. 

On the check-in, I ask students what their favorite unit is. 

I ask my students about a skill they learned or use often. Then I ask students to give a specific example when they demonstrated teamwork.

My final question asks students what they want to improve.

Depending on the students, these check-ins don’t always yield amazing results, but they always give me a starting point. 

Including student voice is a great way to make physical education report card comments more personalized. It also helps prevent parent pushback because the students have a say in their PE comments.

If you’re looking for a free student check-in sheet, click here to get your download.

Digital or Physical Check-In

Depending on your class setup, you can give your student check-in physically or digitally.

If you choose to go the digital route, then I would suggest having your students do a Google Form. This way you can export the results into a spreadsheet so you can easily sort your students’ data.

If you go with a printed sheet, then make sure to keep your sheets separated by class and sorted alphabetically by last name. This makes it really easy to look through your student data while completing your Phys Ed report card comments.

Pick Your Comment Format

Once you’ve done your assessment and you have your students’ input, you’re ready to start writing your PE report card comments.

Bullet Points or Paragraphs

The first thing you’ll need to decide is if you want to use bullet points or paragraphs for your physical education report card comments. 

This is generally up to your admin. I’ve been at several schools and each admin has different requirements. If your admin doesn’t say anything when you’re starting to write comments then it’s best to ask first. 

The last thing you want is to write all of your comments and then be told you need to switch them to a different format.

Pronouns

This is another admin choice, but you want to check with your principal if you should be using student pronouns.

When I started teaching, I always used my students’ pronouns when writing Phys Ed report card comments. The pronouns always had to be the ones approved by the student’s parents. 

When I had students with different pronouns than their pronouns assigned at birth, I would have a conversation with the student to let them know the school protocol.

For the last couple of years, however, my school’s format has been to only use “they” and “their” for report card comments. 

These do feel a bit less personal, but it helps in a lot of ways, including making it easier to copy and paste sections of text without missing a “she” or “his”.

Names

The last formatting issue you need to get out of the way is what names to use.

Some schools allow teachers to write their students’ nicknames or chosen names on report cards. Others require you to use their legal name. 

This can be a bit confusing if you’ve never used a student’s legal name in class, but it’s best to get the information ahead of time so you don’t have to go back and replace names later, although this is a pretty easy fix.

Easy Tips for Writing Personalized Phys Ed Report Card Comments

Focus on Standards to Write Phys Ed Report Card Comments

Now you’re all set to write your amazing and personalized physical education report card comments! 

When you’re writing your comments, focus on the standards. Look at the curriculum and take some of the direct language from it to write your PE report card comments.

In my district, we only assess based on the standards of the curriculum, so this doesn’t typically take any extra time to figure out.

What to Avoid Talking About

One area that I normally see teachers talk about when writing their PE report card comments is which units they covered during the reporting period. 

I typically stay away from this because a report card is about how well each specific student did in a class, not about the class in general.

I’ll mention a specific unit if a student had particular strengths or areas of improvement in the unit. 

Another thing that some teachers talk about is student attitude. In my district, we aren’t allowed to say anything about student attitude or even “Student Name was a pleasure to have in the class”.

However, if your curriculum includes aspects of attitude, then feel free to add PE report card comments about this.  

Begin With Student Strengths

Start with your students’ strengths. Look back through your assessment notes and your student check-in sheets to help you with this process.

My plan of action is to look at a student’s highest overall standard mark. Then I look at the specific unit that they have the best mark in, with regards to the highest overall standard mark and I look at the notes I have written from that unit.

I use these three pieces of information to write the Phys Ed report card comment. 

For example:

“Student Name consistently demonstrated an exceptional work ethic and level of competence during skill development processes. This was seen most evidently during our Olympic Lifting unit. Student Name showed resiliency through adapting attempts to find success with various lifting techniques.”

“Student Name has displayed an adequate level of confidence and competence in the skill development process. This was seen most evidently during our rugby unit when they worked to learn how to do a pop pass and a spin pass with various amounts of defense.”

“Student Name has shown growth throughout the term in their ability to perform and refine movement skills, demonstrate fair play and teamwork, and apply strategies for leading a healthy life. Student Name has worked on demonstrating teamwork and focusing on fair play. This was seen most evidently in the Aussie Rules’ Football unit when they kept a positive attitude and lifted up their teammates’ spirits.”

Each of these examples focuses on a specific standard that students are either strong in or have shown growth in throughout the reporting period. I also try to give a specific example from a unit that I can highlight for the student and their parents.

If you aren’t sure of a specific example to give, look back at the students’ check-in form for ideas.

Start with the Positive When Writing Personalized Physical Education Report Card Comments

What If You Don’t Know a Student’s Strength?

There are some students who choose to sit out for most of our classes and it can feel really hard to find a positive thing to say about them. 

One thing that I often do is use a similar idea from the examples above, but switch up the vocabulary. 

For example, instead of saying: 

“Student Name consistently demonstrated an exceptional work ethic and level of competence during skill development processes.”, 

I might say:

“Student Name occasionally demonstrated a basic work ethic and level of competence during some skill development processes”

Or 

“Student Name demonstrated a simplistic level of competence during skill development processes in our volleyball unit”.

By switching the frequency and accuracy of your chosen standard, you can adapt a comment that you already wrote to more correctly fit a student at a different level.

Whatever you do, make sure you include something positive about each student. I typically try to include 3 sentences, or bullet points, relating to a student’s strengths.

Include Areas of Improvement

Report cards are often called progress reports, so it’s important to remember to include ways that students can improve when writing your physical education report cards.

Try to make sure that your improvement comments still have an air of optimism to them. We want to make sure that our students are encouraged to improve as opposed to feeling defeated.

I tend to list 1 to 2 improvements for my students. 

Some examples of areas of improvement that I use are:

“Student Name will experience greater success as they work to more fully participate in all activities, approach new learning activities with enthusiasm, and strive to involve themselves in gameplay.” 

“Student Name will experience greater success as they work to demonstrate positive communication with their peers, limit distractions, and work to improve their leadership skills by being a positive role model to their peers.

What If There Aren’t Obvious Improvements?

Just like with strengths, there should always be areas of improvement.

The first thing I change is that I say the student will experience “even further” or “even greater” success to show to their adults at home that they’re already doing an amazing job. This is just so they can get even better.

Then I typically focus on the student working on their leadership and citizenship skills. Once they have everything else covered, one of the best ways to improve themselves further is to help build their peers up.

Here is an example:

“Student Name will experience even further success as they work to develop their citizenship skills. This can be accomplished through supporting peers in their learning processes, encouraging classmates, and showing initiative.”

Tips for Writing Personalized Physical Education Report Card Comments

There you have it!

My tips for making writing physical education report card comments easy. Don’t forget to get your student check-in sheet by clicking here so that you have one less thing to worry about and one more thing to make writing your PE report card comments easier.

Let me know what your tips and strategies for writing PE report card comments are by sending me a message over on Instagram @teachingpak.

Have fun out there!

Teaching Pak
This post may contain affiliate links. You pay the same and I get a small commission. Yay! Please see my full disclosure for further information.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Update cookies preferences