Everything You Need to Know About Phys Ed Substitute Teaching

Walking into a new school every day as a substitute teacher can be nerve-racking, but Phys Ed substitute teaching adds an extra layer of nerves.

I still remember my first day of subbing as a physical education teacher. The day went as well as I could’ve hoped for on my first day out of teacher college, but there were so many things that I wasn’t prepared for.

These situations become easier the more you handle them, but in today’s blog post, I want to give you a head start on how you can have the most successful experience being a PE substitute teacher.

There could probably be a hundred tips for being a Phys Ed substitute teacher on this list, but I’ve narrowed it down to my top 12 tips for being a physical education substitute teacher.

Did you know that I have a physical education free resources library that’s filled with lesson plans, resources, and other teacher helps? Click here to join the free resource library!

Everything You Need to Know About Phys Ed Substitute Teaching

1. Always Bring a Whistle to Phys Ed Substitute Teaching

Whenever you’re teaching Phys Ed as a sub, make sure to bring a whistle. Some teachers may leave handheld whistles for you to use, but most won’t.

Having a whistle makes your classroom management a little bit easier. Classroom management is always very important, especially when you’re in physical education because it is much louder, more chaotic, and more injuries can happen than in a classroom.

My favorite whistle has always been this Fox 40 whistle. It has a good sound and volume.

I always use my whistle when I’m teaching PE to get the students’ attention. They will generally instinctively be quieter when they hear the whistle. This allows you to say “freeze”, or “come in”, or give small adjustments to your instructions.

2. Dress in Athletic Wear as a PE Substitute Teacher

If you’re subbing for a class that is anything other than physical education, you will generally wear business casual.

However, PE substitute teaching is a different beast.

Always come wearing athletic wear. I generally wear track pants, a hoodie, and my running shoes. You should be prepared to demonstrate the skills to the students, which means you need to have the range of motion from your clothing to be able to do that.

One time I was booked to substitute for a middle school math and science class. I got to the school, walked into the classroom, and there was the teacher.

She had forgotten to cancel me as a sub… 

Luckily for me, my district has a substitute teacher desk that we can call if something like this happens. 

I called them and they said that I could either take a half day’s pay and not take a job, or I could take a different job. 

I decided to take a different job and it was for Phys Ed. Because I had been planning on teaching in a classroom, I was not dressed appropriately, haha.

Let me tell you, you absolutely want to be wearing flexible clothing anytime you are subbing for physical education.

A tip within a tip. I would suggest always carrying a whistle, a change of athletic clothes, and running shoes in your car. On the flip side, I would also suggest having a business casual outfit ready to go.

This way you’re always prepared for any weird changes in schedules you might get once you get to the school.

Arrive Early to Your Phys Ed Substitute Teaching Job

3. Get To Your Phys Ed Substitute Teaching Job Early

Always get to the school that you’re substitute teaching at early. My district requires substitute teachers to arrive 15 minutes early. In my experience, that’s not enough time.

Try to get to the school as early as possible, so that you can be prepared for your day.

When you arrive at the school, look over the lesson plans. Make sure you know what you’re going to be doing throughout the day.

If you’re unfamiliar with any of the games or sports that have been left for you or the lesson are unclear, make sure to ask other Phys Ed teachers in the department. 

If there aren’t other PE teachers at the school, you can search on YouTube for videos on how to do specific skills or the games that are listed.

In addition to the Phys Ed substitute lesson plans, see if the teacher has left a substitute teaching binder or something similar.

If they left a sub binder for you, then make sure to read through it. This often has information about routines, policies about changing and water/bathroom breaks, where the first aid kit and ice machine are, etc. It will also go over what to do in case of an emergency so that you’re prepared.

Some teachers leave a lot of notes in the binder which can take a while to read through. Each school has their own unique way of doing things and to make your life easier as a substitute teacher, you want to make sure that you follow their routines as closely as possible.

Next, look for an equipment list so that you can get all of your equipment sorted before the students get there.

I’m not sure if you’ve experienced this, but every time I go into a new equipment room it’s like going on a treasure hunt. The teacher has said that you need specific equipment, but you need to sift through bins and bins to find exactly what you’re looking for.

Give yourself the extra time because you never know how organized a storage room will be. Some teachers will have left the equipment out for you, which is always such a treat, but never expect this to happen.

12 Tips for Phys Ed Substitute Teachers

4. Come Prepared With Extra Games

In my experience, most of the teachers that I’m subbing for in Phys Ed are really good at leaving detailed substitute lesson plans. Most of the time I’m able to come in and teach the lessons, from start to finish, without any issues.

However, just like with everything when you’re substitute teaching, you always need to be extra prepared.

Always have two or three low or no equipment games up your sleeve that you can play with the students if the class is not going the way that it was planned, you finish early, or any other unforeseen circumstance arises.

Here are three super easy no prep games that you can play as a physical education substitute teacher if things don’t go as planned. I’ve used these in elementary, middle, and high school.

1. Elephant Soccer

Split the students into groups of 8-12. Have each group of students stand in a circle with their feet in a wide “V” shape. Have all of the students touch their feet together. Give each group of students one dodgeball.

The students will hinge at their hips and put their arms in front of them similar to how they would if they were doing a forearm pass in volleyball.

One student will start with the ball and they will hit the ball to another student, attempting to score the ball through the legs of the person they are hitting towards.

The person that gets the ball sent to them, will use their arms (or elephant trunks) to try to block their legs and send the ball to somebody else.

If the ball goes through the student’s legs, the person that shot the ball will get a point. The person that was scored on will have to put one of their arms behind their back (if a student scores when they only have one arm, then they get their second arm back).

If they’re scored on a second time then they stay standing, without their arms. They can still participate! If a rogue ball goes through their legs, they are back in the game with both arms!

To make things more challenging you can add an additional dodgeball so that students have more to focus on.

2. Last Person Standing Tag

All students fend for themselves. Students can run in all directions in the playing area. The students can team up to play against other groups of students. When a student is tagged, they have to sit down.

  • When students are down, they can tag a standing student. If the standing student is tagged, the standing student has to sit down and the sitting student can stand up
  • When a student is tagged, they sit down. Any student that was tagged by them, gets to stand back up (just like revenge tag/dodgeball)
  • The teacher can yell “Gauntlet” and all of the students that are standing have to run and touch the center of the gym. They can be tagged by anyone that is sitting
  • The teacher can yell, “Freeze” and every student that is sitting down must stay down for the rest of the game

The last student standing wins!

3. Speedball

Speedball is a combination of soccer and handball.

Split the students into four groups. There will be two games going on. Each team will need a net (or two pylons set up to make a goal). Each team is allowed one goalkeeper. Each game will have one soft ball — foam ball, dodgeball, etc. — (you can add a second to increase participation).

The game begins with a jump ball. If the ball is caught in the air, then the students may pass to their teammates’ hands, just like in handball. If the student has the ball they are allowed to take a maximum of 3 steps before they have to pass to a teammate or shoot on the net.

If at any point the ball touches the ground, then it becomes a game of soccer. If the ball is on the ground, students aren’t able to pick the ball back up.

If they want the game to return to handball, one student will need to kick the ball up to a teammate who then catches it. Handball resumes until the ball touches the ground again.

If a student scores by throwing the ball, it’s worth 1 point. If a student scores by kicking the ball, it’s worth 2 points.

5. Be Confident as a PE Substitute Teacher

Even if you don’t feel confident being a physical education substitute teacher, you need to show confident body language to the students.

Students are much more likely to listen to you as a substitute teacher, which can always be challenging when you go into a new situation with students (especially middle schoolers), when you demonstrate confident body language.

This video from Joe Navarro is a great crash course on demonstrating confidence. He is a leading expert in body language and I highly recommend checking out his books and any YouTube video he is in.

6. Greet the PE Students at the Door

Now that you’ve arrived early at your substitute teaching assignment, and you’ve prepped for the lesson, you’re ready for the students to come!

Make sure to greet the students at the door and give them a friendly “hello”. You’ll probably get a lot of questions about where their teacher is (if their teacher hasn’t already told them that they’ll be missing).

If you’re at a school that requires the students to get changed, then make sure to give them about 5 minutes to be prepared for class.

7. Learn the Names of the Phys Ed Students

One of the hardest things about being a substitute teacher, and especially a PE substitute teacher, is learning the students’ names. Classroom management is so much harder when you don’t know any of their names.

Once the students arrive, get them to sit down in front of you, in their pods, or doing the instant activity that their teacher has left.

Next, make sure that you take attendance. The teacher you’re subbing for should have left you a class list, but if they didn’t, then make sure to ask the office to print it off for you when you’re reading through the lesson plans before school starts.

When you’re taking attendance, make sure to look the students in the eyes when you call their names. Try to remember as many names as you can as you’re looking at the student’s faces. 

If you’re given two copies of the classlist, then you can write specific characteristics about the students next to their names so that you can remember who they are more easily.

For example, Samantha has brown hair that she is wearing in a braided bun. Omar has a Green Bay Packers shirt on.

These little reminders can make a big difference when you’re trying to remember the students’ names throughout the class.

8. Pick Your Battles

It comes as no surprise that when students don’t have their regular teacher, they don’t behave as well.

This can make substitute teaching pretty taxing.

However, my best tip for dealing with this is to pick your battles.

There are going to be situations that absolutely require attention such as fights or injuries. But, not everything is something that you can and should deal with when you see the students for 1 hour one time.

For example, one of the biggest issues I see is substitute teachers trying to force the students to dress in their gym strip. 

Yes, we would love to have all the students dressed out for Phys Ed. But, if you aren’t the regular physical education teacher, this is a battle you probably don’t want to fight. 

You can ask the students to change, but if they fight you on it, there isn’t really a lot that you can do to make them change and it’s best not to have a power struggle over it.

Instead, just write a note for yourself so that you can let the teacher know at the end of the day.

When in doubt, try to resolve an issue. If you can’t resolve it and it’s not a safety concern, then write a note for the teacher. If it’s a safety concern then call down to the office to get the administration to help you.

Follow the Lesson Plan When Substitute Teaching in Physical Education

9. Follow the PE Lesson Plan

The physical education teacher has probably written out fairly detailed substitute lesson plans.

Follow the lesson plans as closely as you can.

If the teacher gets the students attention by blowing their whistle two times, then make sure you blow your whistle two times.

If the teacher gets the students’ attention by yelling, “Freeze”, then do that.

One of the best ways to make your time as a PE substitute teacher be as smooth as possible is following the routines that the typical Phys Ed teacher does.

If you’re left a game to play with the students, and the teacher has said that the students know how to play the game, then ask the students to explain the game to you before you start.

This helps you understand the rules, but holds the students accountable for playing the game correctly and appropriately.

Make sure you include any warm-ups and cool-downs that the teacher has suggested.

If they leave specific lengths of time that each activity should be played for, try to stick to that as best as you can.

Don’t forget about the games you came prepared with. If you have a little bit of time at the end of class you could pull one of those out.

10. Circulate and Keep Your Eyes Up as a Phys Ed Substitute Teacher

Classroom management through proximity. 

Physical education can be chaotic at the best of times. But one of the best ways to mitigate this is by being as involved as possible.

Make sure you are moving around the gym, fitness room, or wherever your class is taking place. Talk with the students and try to build any type of relationship that you can during this time.

Make sure that while you’re moving around you’re also looking at the opposite side of the playing area at the same time.

Sometimes students will behave when you’re close to them but as soon as you move away they feel more comfortable horsing around. By looking into the distance while close to another group you can see if anything else is going on away from you.

If you notice the students are behaving inappropriately, then calmly head over to them and remind them of the expectations and rules that you have for them.

Don’t forget about the tips we already talked about above, with picking your battles and when to involve administration.

11. Have the Students Help with Clean Up

Leave plenty of time for the students to help with cleanup and get changed.

The last thing you need is to be all frazzled by not having equipment ready for the next class that is coming into the gym in 3 minutes.

Have the students return the equipment back to where you need it for the start of your lesson.

Only after the students have helped clean up are they allowed to get changed.

Make sure you’re also helping the students clean up. There will be some helpful students that will help you clean up no matter what, but if the other students see you standing around “not doing anything”, they may think that they don’t have to do it either.

12. Leave a Note For the Teacher

Make sure you take notes throughout the class for the teacher.

I typically write my notes on the lesson plan that I’m given. This way I can organize my notes for each period or block. This makes it easier for the teacher when they return.

Let the teacher know what you got accomplished during the class, which students were extra helpful, any serious behavior issues that the teacher should follow up with, or anything else you think would be important for the teacher to know when they return.

Lastly, if you’re interested in returning to that school again, be sure to leave your name, phone number, and email. You can even leave a business card if you have one handy.

Remember that the teacher will talk to their colleagues at the school and you may be able to get substitute teaching jobs in other classes at the same school.

A Beginner's Guide to Phys Ed Substitute Teaching

There you have it! My 12 tips for being a Phys Ed substitute teacher. Hopefully, after reading this post, you feel prepared and excited for taking on any physical education guest teacher positions that come your way.

If you’re looking for a more permanent job, then be sure to check out my blog posts on job interviews: How to Prepare for a Physical Education Interview So You Can Land the Job of Your Dreams and Crush your Physical Education Interview by Preparing Answers to These 15 Questions

Did I miss any tips? Let me know by sending me a message on Instagram @teachingpak

Have fun out there!

Teaching Pak
This post may contain affiliate links. You pay the same and I get a small commission. Yay! Please see my full disclosure for further information.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Update cookies preferences