So your PE teacher evaluations are coming up soon?
If you’re anything like me, you don’t like when admin comes into your physical education class, whether planned or unannounced.
I always get really nervous whenever I’m getting observed. So much so that I managed to slide under the radar for the first two years of my teaching career so that I wouldn’t have to get evaluated.
But, I started at a new school the following year and within the first week, my assistant principal told me that she wanted to do my evaluations so that I could get my permanent teaching certificate.
Although I was really hesitant, I knew how important it was going to be to my teaching career. And let’s be honest, I could only get out of being evaluated for so long.
Since then, I’ve been evaluated every year, and even though I still get nervous, I have strategies that help me prepare for my observations.
In this blog post, I’ll give you 8 tips to nail your physical education teacher evaluation.
Looking for more secondary physical education resources? Click here to join the Free Resource Library to get access to free lesson plans, templates, and other PE teaching resources! If you never want to make another lesson plan again, click here to shop my pre-made detailed unit plans from my Teachers Pay Teachers store.
1. Stick to the Plan for Your PE Teacher Evaluations
I’m in a PE teacher Facebook group and every so often I see teachers ask if any of the teachers in the group have a good lesson to use for their Phys Ed teaching evaluation.
But I think the best thing for you to do is to stick to the lesson that you were originally planning for.
For example, if you’re going to have your PE teacher evaluation on the second lesson of your lacrosse unit and you were originally going to teach scooping, then that’s what you should stick to.
First of all, it makes it easier for your students if you keep the consistency. If they’re in the middle of a unit, switching to something different for one day can make them confused, which ultimately can cause more classroom management and behavior issues.
It also means less additional planning for you.
2. Look at Your Assessment Rubric
Before your physical education teacher evaluation, you should look at the rubric you’ll be assessed on.
Just like with our students, it’s always best to know how you’re going to be evaluated so that you’re ready for your evaluation.
There might be some things that your evaluator is looking for that you need to be prepared to show them.
When I’m being assessed, one of the things my principal is looking for is having an inclusive class. Although I do have an inclusive Phys Ed class, when I’m being evaluated, I like to write down the specifics of what I do so that it’s easy for me to answer when my admin asks.
If there are aspects that you’re being evaluated on, but won’t be seen in your lesson then you should write out how you have done them in previous lessons or will be doing them in future lessons.
3. Create Solid Lesson Plans For Your Phys Ed Teaching Evaluation
Creating thought-out lesson plans is always important because they keep your PE lessons focused, help to make learning tasks flow and make sure you cover all of your standards for the day.
Making lesson plans is even more important when you’re being evaluated.
Your admin will probably ask you for your lesson plan ahead of time so that they know you’re prepped for your evaluation and to get an idea of what you’ll be teaching. Many evaluators aren’t physical education teachers, so they might not know exactly what you do in your class.
Take your time including information in your lesson plans that directly shows how you’re doing the things you’re being evaluated on.
Choose Your Learning Tasks Carefully
You know your students well.
When you’re being evaluated take time to choose learning activities that will keep your students engaged and will actively work on the skills you’re covering in your class.
Try to stick to activities that are easy to manage or that your students are familiar with, even if they’ve only done them in other units.
If you have a supportive admin and you want to try something new, then go for it. You can get a lot of great feedback from your admin. But I would definitely suggest that you let your evaluator know that you are switching things up.
Know the Why Behind Each of Your Learning Activities
In my experience, it seems that my admin’s favorite thing to do is walk around and ask students, “Why are you doing this activity?”.
I’ll be honest, this drives me crazy.
But it’s important to keep in mind.
Each activity you do should have a specific purpose.
Is it helping students practice a skill, applying skills to gameplay, or developing offensive strategies?
You should know why you’re choosing specific activities and how they help accomplish the goals of your curriculum.
Also, make a note on your lesson plans to ask your students why they think they’re completing the tasks, and you can give your answer as well. This helps students understand the “so what” of an activity.

4. Have a Backup Plan
When you’re making your lesson plan for your Phys Ed teacher evaluation, don’t forget to also come up with a backup plan. I always say to overplan because it’s way better to have too many activities than too few.
Come up with different activities you can use if you have a little extra time at the end.
Also, jot down a couple of alternative games or drills you can use if the activities you planned aren’t working.
When you’re teaching during your PE teacher evaluation, don’t be afraid to switch up your lesson. Yes, you made your lesson plan, but if an activity just isn’t working then don’t try to force it. Switch your activity so that your students are still completing the same learning objectives but in a different way.
This shows your admin that you are adaptable and willing to change your plans to help your students be successful.
5. Prep Your Students Before Your Physical Education Teacher Evaluation
Take this tip with a grain of salt.
You know your students best. I’ve had some classes who will behave normally or on their best behavior when I let them know ahead of time that the principal will be observing our class.
But, there are some classes and students that go out of their way to make your physical education teacher evaluation more challenging if they know why admin is there.
Think about what would be best for your class and go from there.
Introduce Your Evaluator
Even if I don’t prep my class before my evaluation day, I always make sure to introduce my evaluator when they arrive.
I say something along the lines of, “Class, Ms. Assistant Principal is here in our class today. Make sure to make her feel welcome”.
This serves two purposes.
One, I honestly do want the admin to feel comfortable in my class.
And two, it helps the students that often require more classroom management to acknowledge that there is admin in the class and they’re more likely to behave more appropriately.

6. Move Around During Your Phys Ed Teacher Evaluation
This is something that you’re probably already doing when you’re teaching, but make sure to move around and interact with all of your students during your Phys Ed teacher evaluation. This is a key component of showing your admin how you have positive pedagogical relationships with your students.
Seeing you interact with all of your students is important for your evaluator to see you teaching in large groups as well as in small groups and one-on-one.
It also helps with classroom management, so it’s a great way to keep your lessons on track.
7. Do Your Best
You’re a great Phys Ed teacher. Don’t ever forget that.
Sometimes your PE Teacher evaluation won’t go as planned, but just do your best during your lesson. This might be a cliche, but just do the best you can and things will work out.
There will always be something that goes wrong, but that’s okay.
Stay present and focused and you’ll be able to overcome anything that comes your way!
8. Be Open to Your Phys Ed Teacher Observation Feedback
It can be so hard getting feedback from anyone, but especially administration.
So, be open to all of the feedback from your evaluator. They (in almost all situations) want you to be successful, so they’ll give you feedback to make you an even better teacher.
If you disagree with what they have to say, look for something that you do agree with, but don’t be afraid to let them know you don’t agree. Make sure to wait until they’re finished talking about the area you disagree with before you start talking.
Then explain your perspective and respectfully explain how you disagree with them and give them counter-points.
Keep your emotions in check because, like I said, they really are trying to help.
Also, try to apply their suggestions.
A lot of teachers think, “No, I’m not going to do that”. Even if you think their ideas would never work in your classes, I say to just give it a go and maybe you’ll be pleasantly surprised.

There you have it. My top 8 tips for navigating your Phys Ed teacher observation. I hope that you have a successful evaluation!
Am I missing any tips for PE teacher evaluations? Send me a message over on Instagram @TeachingPak or comment down below and let’s connect!
Have fun out there!





